Cyber Insurance Requirements for Small Business

Cyber Insurance Requirements for Small Business: What Insurers Expect

Many business owners meet their cyber insurance requirements for the first time at renewal, when a questionnaire arrives with dozens of technical questions and a short deadline. Some of those questions are easy to answer. Others require a look at how email, backups, laptops and sign-ins are actually configured. This checklist walks through what applications commonly ask, so you can prepare before the form lands on your desk.

The short answer: Cyber insurance applications commonly ask whether a business uses multi-factor authentication, endpoint protection, tested backups, regular security updates, email filtering, employee security training and a written incident response plan. Requirements differ by insurer, policy and business type, so the questions on your own application are the authority. A business that already has these basics in place can usually complete an application accurately and with far less stress.
Important note: Urban IT is a managed IT services provider. We are not an insurance broker or agent, and nothing in this article is insurance, legal or financial advice. Your policy language and your broker determine what is covered and what is required.

What cyber insurance does and does not do

Cyber insurance generally helps pay for costs that follow a security incident, which can include investigation, notification, legal help, business interruption and in some cases extortion payments, depending on the policy. It does not prevent an incident, and it does not repair a damaged reputation. Policies also include conditions and exclusions. Reading them with your broker, particularly the sections on security requirements and on how a claim is evaluated, is time well spent.

Insurers ask security questions because they price risk. A business with strong basic controls is less likely to file a claim, so these controls influence whether coverage is offered, and on what terms. Because requirements change as the market changes, treat the list below as common themes and not as a guarantee of what any one insurer will ask. For a sense of what real questionnaires look like, the State of Indiana publishes sample underwriting questions that include whether the applicant requires MFA for web-based email, uses endpoint detection and response on all endpoints, and tests backups for restorability.


The controls insurers commonly ask about

Multi-factor authentication

This is among the most frequent questions. Applications often ask separately about MFA on email, on remote access, and on administrator or privileged accounts. Answering “yes, for everyone, everywhere” requires knowing the exceptions. Our guide to multi-factor authentication for small business explains the methods and a sensible rollout order.

Endpoint protection on every computer

Insurers want to know whether laptops, desktops and servers run security software that goes beyond traditional antivirus, and whether it is monitored by someone. Applications may use terms like EDR, MDR or XDR. If those terms are unfamiliar, see our explanation of EDR and why antivirus is no longer enough.

Backups that can be restored

The question is rarely just “do you have backups.” Applications often ask whether backups are separated from the main network so ransomware cannot encrypt them, whether they cannot be altered or deleted for a period of time, and whether restores have actually been tested. Cloud services need attention here too, because the provider keeping a service running is not the same as backing up your data. We explain that distinction in does Microsoft 365 back up your data.

Patching and software updates

Expect questions about how quickly critical security updates are applied to computers, servers, firewalls and other network equipment, and whether any systems run software that the manufacturer no longer supports.

Email security

Most incidents begin with email. Applications may ask about spam and phishing filtering, protection against malicious links and attachments, and whether your domain has email authentication records such as SPF, DKIM and DMARC. Our guide to DMARC covers the last of these.

Employee security awareness training

Insurers often ask whether staff receive regular security training and whether phishing simulations are run. The training does not need to be elaborate, but it does need to be recurring and recorded. Our article on spotting phishing scams is a useful starting point for staff.

Privileged access and administrator accounts

Questions here include how many people have administrator rights, whether administrators use separate accounts for daily work, and how shared or default passwords are handled.

Incident response plan

Many applications ask whether you have a written plan that says who does what in the first hours of an incident, who to call, and how decisions are made. A plan that lives only in one person’s head is not a plan.

Financial transaction controls

Because wire fraud and invoice fraud are common, some applications ask whether payment changes are verified by a call to a known phone number before money moves. This is a process control, not a technology purchase.


A printable-style checklist

Use this list to see where you stand. Anything you cannot answer with confidence is worth looking into before the application arrives.

  • MFA is required for all email accounts.
  • MFA is required for remote access and for every administrator account.
  • Every computer and server runs monitored endpoint protection.
  • Backups run on a schedule, are kept separate from the main network, and cannot be quickly altered or deleted by an attacker.
  • A restore from backup has been tested within the last year, and the date is recorded.
  • Critical security updates are applied on a defined schedule for computers, servers and firewalls.
  • No business-critical system is running software that is out of support.
  • Email filtering is in place and the domain has SPF, DKIM and DMARC configured.
  • Employees receive security awareness training on a recurring basis.
  • Administrators use separate accounts, and the list of who has administrator rights is reviewed.
  • A written incident response plan exists, including contact details for your IT provider, insurer and legal counsel.
  • Payment instruction changes are verified by phone with a known contact before funds are sent.
  • You have an up-to-date list of the computers, servers and cloud services your business uses.

Why accuracy on the application matters

It is tempting to answer “yes” to a question when a control is mostly in place. The risk is that the answers on the application are generally part of the basis on which the policy is issued, and an inaccurate answer can create problems if a claim is later reviewed. If a control is only partly deployed, such as MFA on most but not all accounts, say so or finish the job before you submit. Your broker can advise on how to word partial answers. When the application asks something you cannot verify yourself, ask your IT provider to confirm the facts so that the person signing the form is not guessing.


What to gather before renewal

  • The current application or renewal questionnaire, and last year’s answers for comparison.
  • A list of users and which of them have MFA enabled.
  • A list of computers and servers with their security software status and operating system versions.
  • Backup details: what is backed up, how often, where copies are stored, and the date of the last restore test.
  • Training records, such as completion dates.
  • Your incident response plan, or a note that one needs to be written.
  • Any changes during the year, such as new offices, new cloud services, acquisitions or staff in new locations.

Starting four to six weeks before the renewal date leaves room to fix gaps instead of only reporting them.


How compliance frameworks overlap

Many of these controls also appear in compliance requirements for regulated industries such as healthcare, financial services and professional services. Work done for one purpose often supports another. If your business faces requirements such as HIPAA or the FTC Safeguards Rule, see how our IT compliance services approach them.


Frequently asked questions about cyber insurance requirements

Is a cyber insurance policy required by law?
There is generally no general legal requirement for a business to carry cyber insurance. Clients, landlords, lenders or contracts may require it, so check agreements you have signed.
Will meeting these controls lower my premium?
Premiums depend on the insurer, your industry, your revenue and your claims history, among other things. Strong controls can improve your chances of being offered coverage and may affect terms, but no one can promise a particular price. Your broker is the right person to ask.
What if I cannot answer a question on the application?
Do not guess. Ask your IT provider to confirm the facts, or ask your broker whether the question can be answered with an explanation. It is better to be accurate and plan to fix a gap than to give an answer you cannot support.
Do small businesses really need all of these controls?
Insurers ask the same core questions of businesses of many sizes, because attackers do not skip small organizations. Smaller businesses can meet them with a well-chosen, practical set of tools, and many of these controls reduce the likelihood of an incident regardless of insurance.
Does having cyber insurance mean we do not need a security provider?
No. Insurance helps with costs after an incident. Security controls help to prevent the incident and to limit its impact. The two work together, and a policy may require the controls to be in place.
Who should fill out the application?
The business owner or an authorized officer signs it, and your IT provider should supply and verify the technical answers. Your broker can help interpret questions and coverage choices.

The bottom line

Cyber insurance questionnaires are a practical to-do list for basic security. If you can honestly check off MFA, monitored endpoint protection, tested backups, timely updates, email protection, training and a written response plan, you are in a solid position. If you cannot, the application is a useful prompt to close the gaps.

If you would like help confirming what is actually in place before your next renewal, talk to Urban IT about a review of your security controls. You can also read about our cybersecurity services.

Talk to Urban IT

This article is general information for business owners. It is not insurance, legal or financial advice, and Urban IT is not an insurance broker or agent. Consult your broker and attorney about your own policy and obligations.

Similar Posts